Home › Guides › Net vs impact screen
Golf net vs impact screen: which should you buy?
A net catches the ball; a screen catches the ball and shows you the course life-size. One costs a few hundred dollars and fits a small room, the other costs thousands and wants more space. Here's how to pick without regret.
This decision gets made backwards a lot of the time — people buy a projector and screen because that's what looks good in YouTube videos, then discover their room is 9 ft deep and the numbers don't work. Or they buy the cheapest pop-up net they can find and it's dead in a month. Both parts of a simulator — what stops the ball and what shows you the shot — deserve a real decision, not a default. This guide walks through the actual trade-off: cost, room depth, immersion, and what each option means for safety, so you can match the choice to your space instead of your Pinterest board.
Prices are indicative 2026 ranges (USD) — check current pricing before buying.
The short version
A net + TV setup is the budget, small-room route: you hit into a net, a launch monitor reads the ball, and ball flight plays on a regular television. Total added cost for the net and mounting is roughly $150–500 on top of your launch monitor, and because there's no screen to protect, you don't need the same 16–18 ft of total room depth that a full enclosure wants — though the 10 ft ball-to-net safety minimum still applies. An impact screen + projector setup swaps the TV for a tensioned fabric screen and a projector, so the course is projected life-size in front of you. That's the immersive, "I'm actually on the course" feeling — and it adds roughly $1,000–3,000 for the screen, enclosure or frame, and projector, plus it wants a room built around that screen size and standoff distance.
| Net + TV | Impact screen + projector | |
|---|---|---|
| Added cost | $150–500 | $1,000–3,000+ |
| Room depth needed | Less forgiving room still needs the 10 ft ball-to-net minimum, but no big screen to fit | Wants 16–18 ft total for comfort; 10 ft ball-to-screen is a hard minimum |
| Immersion | Low — you watch a TV off to the side or on a stand | High — life-size course projected in front of you |
| Setup complexity | Simple — net, launch monitor, TV, done | More involved — frame or enclosure, screen tensioning, projector mount and throw distance |
| Best for | Small rooms, tight budgets, garages you also park in | Dedicated rooms where you want the full experience |
When net + TV is the right call
- Your room is small or shared. If depth is tight, or the space doubles as a garage bay, guest room or storage, a net-and-TV rig is far easier to live with — it's not a permanent installation.
- You're not sure this is a long-term hobby yet. Spending $200 to find out you love it beats spending $2,500 on a screen and enclosure first.
- Budget is the deciding factor. Every dollar not spent on a screen and enclosure is a dollar available for a better launch monitor — see builds under $2,000.
- You mainly want practice, not the full-course feel. If you're there to groove your swing and check numbers, watching flight on a TV works fine — the launch monitor's data is identical either way.
When an impact screen earns its keep
- You have a dedicated room. A garage bay, basement or spare bedroom that exists for the simulator and nothing else is exactly what a screen setup wants — see garage builds or basement builds.
- You care about the experience, not just the numbers. Standing over a shot with the fairway projected life-size in front of you is a genuinely different feeling than glancing at a TV — this is the "I'd rather be here than at the range" upgrade.
- You're hosting. Friends and family engage far more with a big projected course than a small screen off to the side.
- Your room already clears the depth numbers. If you're already at 16 ft+ of usable depth, you're leaving experience on the table by not using a screen. Check the exact numbers in the impact screen size guide.
The honest part
A screen setup in a room that's genuinely too shallow is the single most common regret we see described. People stretch to 12 ft of total depth, cram the enclosure in, and end up standing closer to the screen than the 10 ft ball-to-screen safety minimum allows — which means dialing back swing speed indoors, which defeats the point. If your depth is under about 14 ft, run the numbers honestly before you commit to a screen; a net-and-TV rig at that depth will feel like the right decision in six months, not the compromise one. On the flip side, don't assume a net is automatically "safe" just because it's cheaper — see the net-safety guide below. And don't buy a screen because a build video made it look essential: plenty of serious home setups run net-and-TV permanently and never look back, especially in garages that still need to fit a car.
First, make sure it fits
Both options share the same non-negotiable: 10 ft of ball-to-fabric distance, whether that fabric is a net or a screen. Everything else — total depth, width, ceiling — depends on your actual room, not a generic recommendation.
Where to look for either one
For a net, look at retailers that sell simulator-specific netting rather than generic backyard practice nets — the difference in stopping power matters. For a screen, a matched enclosure-and-screen kit removes the guesswork on tensioning and projector throw.
Shop golf nets → Compare enclosure kits & screens →
FAQ
- Can you use a TV instead of an impact screen?
- Yes. A net-plus-TV setup is a legitimate way to run a simulator — you hit into the net and watch ball flight on a normal TV instead of a projected screen. You lose the life-size immersion of a projected image, but you save money and need less room depth.
- Is a golf net safe indoors?
- A net is safe indoors only if it's rated to stop full-speed driver shots, sized well beyond your swing arc, and backed by a solid wall rather than a window or thin drywall over glass. A flimsy net or one placed too close will let balls punch through or bounce back.
- How far from the net should you hit?
- Keep at least 10 ft between the ball and the net or screen as a hard safety minimum — the same distance used for impact screens — so a mishit loses energy before it reaches the fabric. Add stance room in front of that on top.
Related
Best golf nets, by category · Impact screen size · DIY enclosure guide · Room-fit calculator